Your Trusted Homemaker Service In Cuyahoga County


Our agency helps those with developmental disabilities and other care needs be more independent while meeting their daily living goals.

Located in Painesville, OH, the All Starr Care Agency provides quality Homemaker and Personal Care (HPC) services to adults living in Cuyahoga County, Lake County, and Geauga County. Established in 2022, our agency’s mission is to support the success of individuals with mental and physical limitations, strengthen their families, and build embracing communities. Furthermore, our compassionate team members empower clients by providing them with the best options and opportunities to live safely, learn continuously, explore their creativity, and work productively throughout their lifetimes. In exchange for our HPC services, we accept both private pay and insurance payments.

While serving the local community, we are committed to protecting and promoting the rights, free will, and contentment of clients of all ages, races, and beliefs.

The Leadership Team at the All Starr Care Agency has many decades of combined hands-on experience while assisting individuals with mental and physical disabilities. For the added protection of our clients, all our employees are screened thoroughly, including criminal and driving background checks. While putting the needs of our clients first, we are constantly striving to deliver quality services that support their highest level of independence. In addition to Homemaker and Personal Care services, our direct care professionals are trained on the latest safety protocols and social building techniques. Contact us today to learn more about our agency or schedule a consultation!

Our Leadership

Meet Our Team

Keisha Smith

Keisha Smith

CEO/Director of Operations

Keisha has a Master’s Degree in Special Education and over 15 years of experience educating students with multiple disabilities. She has experience as working as a personal provider and owns and operates a home for the mentally disabled. Keisha is passionate about the work that she does and takes pride in making a difference in the lives of others. Her years of experience and dedication to her career has led her to become an agency provider.

Jeffrey Smith

Jeffrey Smith

Quality Assurance Manager

Jeff has years of experience in overseeing daily operations, developing budgets, hiring and training staff, scheduling employees, and implementing programs.

LaTonya Ayers

LaTonya Ayers

Administrative Support

LaTonya Ayers graduated from Tiffin University in 2011 earning her Bachelor of Business Degree. LaTonya serves as the administrative support to the Director of Operations and staff to ensure the All Starr Care Agency compliance requirements are maintained for the health, safety, and welfare of the clients served. LaTonya also has experience working as a DSP in a group home setting and Health Unit Coordinator at the Cleveland Clinic hospital.